But what determines how "good" it is? How fun, right? That could include how new innovations, technology, or gameplay ideas make it more enjoyable, but it also takes into account ease of play and community, which is different for everybody
If I played xbox 360 games all my life or at least console games, I would enjoy a game like COD much more just because it's easier to play. Just think, how much fun is dodgeball if all that ever happens to you is getting hit with the ball, and how much LESS fun it is if you get hit in the nuts every single time! That's what playing COD is like for me.. I can barely go two feet without getting killed.
then again I've never practiced very long with it :P
that's my rant for the day